I need everyone's help! Last week I found a pair of UGG Argyle Knit boots that I have wanted since last year for $90 (original retail is $140). I was super excited. I got them from a ski shop out in California that was trying to get rid of the last few pairs it had. Luckily they had them in my size and the color (charcoal) I wanted (or so I thought). So when I got them, I took them out of the box and noticed they were brown! I know most of you are saying, "who cares? they were $90!" However, my dilemma is because I already have a pair of UGG Classic Tall boots in brown. It's my own fault. The picture of the boots was charcoal, but I clearly picked stout because that was the only color available in my size. I was so excited I found them so cheap I never even thought about it. I love them though, they're so comfy. I have pictures below of both boots side by side.
This is what I wanted
This is what I got
Here's the comparison between what I have. Let me know what you guys think!
Are they too similar? Should I return them and just ask for the charcoal ones for Christmas? See my dilemma?